Health Care BS

The folks at the Nationwide Tea Party Coalition have a few health care questions for the latest Nobel laureate:

And they expect answers before tomorrow’s Senate vote on the Baucus bill. Here they are again for you readerly types:

10 - At a town hall meeting in Raleigh, North Carolina on July 29 you said ” I will be available to answer any question that members of Congress have. If they want to come over to the White House and go over line by line what’s going on, I will be happy to do that.” A month ago, Congressman Phil Roe sent you two letters asking you for a time and place to conduct this line by line review. You’ve not responded to him. Do you intend to honor your promise and sit down with Congressman Roe and hold a serious line by line review of proposed health care legislation or was your July 29 statement merely an insincere political gesture ?

9 - The Administration has repeatedly represented to the American people that the proposed health care reform plan will be deficit-neutral. Referring to the Administration’s plan, the Congressional Budget Office Director recently said “We do not see the sort of fundamental changes that would be necessary to reduce the trajectory of federal health spending by a significant amount.” Official CBO estimates for the Administration’s proposals have, in fact, indicated additional deficits of hundreds of billions of dollars over 10 years. Why should the American people trust the Administration’s numbers rather than those of the C.B.O. on this point?

8 - The health care reform bill currently pending before the Senate Finance Committee includes over $100 billion in cuts to Medicare. The Administration promises that the cuts to Medicare will not reduce health care benefits to seniors. The head of the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office recently told senators that the cuts in the bill WILL reduce health care benefits to seniors. Why should seniors trust the Administration more than the nonpartisan C.B.O. on this point?

7 - You have accused the opponents of this Healthcare plan of using “lies” and “scare tactics” and spreading “disinformation.” During your speech on Sept 9, you state that “One man from Illinois lost his coverage in the middle of chemotherapy because his insurer found that he hand’t reported gallstones that he didn’t even know about. They delayed his treatment, AND HE DIED BECAUSE OF IT”. In truth, the man, Otto Raddatz, began chemo and was preparing for a stem cell transplant. During a routine review by the insurer, it was found that he had not disclosed having gallstones and an anuerysm. Mr. Raddatz had never been told about the gallstones or been urged to treat them. His sister, appealed to the Attorney General, who reversed the decision within two weeks and Mr. Raddatz had the transplant and lived another 3 and half years. -an indication that the company’s decision to rescind his treatment didn’t cause his death. Mr. Raddatz didn’t die from being denied treatment, but your speech stated so. How can you accuse critics of creating lies about the healthcare proposal when on several occasions your own words have been found to be untruthful?

6 - The Administration argues for a government-funded health insurance plan on the grounds that more competition is necessary in order to reduce health care costs. In response to a question from CNN’s Wolf Blitzer as to why the Administration’s health care reform plan does not include also interstate competition as a means to reduce costs, David Axelrod responded that “[Interstate competition] is not endemic to the kind of reforms that we’re proposing” At least one study has concluded that interstate competition would be likely to reduce health care costs and reduce the number of uninsured. If competition can be expected to reduce costs and increase coverage, why is interstate competition not ‘endemic’ to the Administration’s proposed reforms? 

5 - You indicated in your interview with George Stephanpolus that if people did not buy insurance that they would be fined a penalty fee but you insisted that it is not a tax. However, on page 29 of the Senate bill that Mr. Stephanopoulus refers to, it states that the fee will be an “excise TAX.” How do you expect Americans to believe you have a grasp and knowlege of the healthcare legislation and are able to run it, when it is apparent that you had not even read the bill? Not even 29 pages of it.

4 - The Administration has repeatedly claimed that its health care reform plan will not cover illegal aliens. The Congressional Research Service recently issued a report contradicting the Administration’s position, stating “H.R. 3200 does not contain any restrictions on non-citizens whether legally or illegally present, or in the United States temporarily or permanently participating in the Exchange.” Is the Congressional Research Service in error? If so, where is the error?

3 - You have said you will pay for healthcare by savings through “waste and fraud”. By this statement then you are indicating that if you are able to quantify the amount in order to turn it into savings, you must be able to identify where it is. If that is true, why aren’t you stopping the waste and fraud now since you can identify it instead of waiting until some unknown deadline? Don’t you think this would engender some trust from the American people that you are making an effort to save money or that you know how to?

2 - Why won’t government employees and elected officials be covered under a nationwide health care plan? Your employer, the American taxpayers, would like to drop your family’s existing coverage and force you into the public option that you so energetically endorse.

1 - Mississippi has adopted lawsuit abuse reform (tort) in their state and has reduced their healthcare premiums by 42% in the last year due to this reform. Gov. Barbour estimates America can save almost 100-200 billion dollars a year implementing just this one reform. Other than the fact that Tort Attorneys and their groups donate heavily to the DNC and did to the Obama campaign, is there a good reason or explanation you can give the American people as to why you have put the Tort attorneys’ interests ahead of the healthcare interests of the citizens of this country?

[HT Michelle Malkin]